Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Gainesville, Fl.
Vehicle: 99 Dakota
Modifications: Quad Cab swap, Cummins swap, Solid axle swap
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18 Post(s)
Yeah, a 4.56 will certainly give you more get-up and go, but with 35's I'd be more concerned about the front wheel bearings and front diff.
The bearings will not be happy with bigger tires and won't last real long if you got the wrong rim offset. Unfortunately, the bearing design just isn't very durable when bigger tires are used.
The front differential housing is made out of aluminum. Normally they hold up fine on stock sized tires, but the bigger tires tends to require more torque to turn (especially in difficult off road terrain if you love using 4wd) When torque on the gears increase, the pinion gear inside the diff wants to separate from the ring gear. Aluminum isn't as strong, so theres more potential for the housing to crack or explode when the gears try to separate.
This was a common issue with the older Dakotas and Durangos which used the Dana 35 front axle. And tire size should be limited to 33s. By the 2000 model year Dodge replaced the Dana 35 for a slightly larger 8.0 corporate front differential, which should hold up to more torque, but the housing is still made out of aluminum and all gears do try to separate under load. So that potential for a crack is still there. I'd suggest you don't push the limits of your truck, if you off road the thing.